Reports & Publications

Tuesday 01 April 2008

Author-perceived Quality Characteristics of STM Journals 2008

Author: Dr John J Regazzi (Scholarly Communications Lab), Selenay Aytac (B Davis Schwartz Memorial Library)
ISBN: 0-907341-38-1 / 978-0-907341-38-3
80 pages, paperback
Non Members (Print & PDF) £70.00
Members (Print Only) £40.00

ALPSP Members: To download this report please go to Reports Access page.

To purchase a copy of this report, please email for further details

The aim of this research study is to explore the author-perceived quality characteristics of science, technology and medicine (STM) journals. One of the most, if not the most, important issue today facing scholarly communication is what constitutes quality in the publishing and dissemination of research findings.

This research, using 16 previously identified and researched measures of quality for STM journals, explores the most important of these measures as well as illustrating what user characteristics might affect quality ratings and perceptions.

The methodology employed was triangulated data from a small number of volunteer full-time faculty members of Long Island University (LIU), using three different research techniques: questionnaire survey, focus groups, and semi-structured face-to-face interviews. To compare the relative strength and importance of all of the previously researched quality factors, the 16 attributes studied were placed into a two-dimensional map classifying the relative strength of each through an integrated measure of importance and awareness for each attribute. The study identified some significant differences by discipline, gender, and tenured status. Overall, the three most important attributes were the reputation of the journal, the estimated length of time to article publication, and the readership of the journal.

The findings bring new insight into this area for the scholarly research community.



There are no comments. Why not be the first?

Add your comment