ALPSP
spacer
Forgotten Password?
Help?
spacer
Remember me?
spacer
spacer
   
small   medium   large   Low graphics version
ALPSP Events
spacer
11 February 2010
Does my content look big in this?
spacer
18 March 2010
The Future of Academic Book Publishing
spacer
19 April 2010
ALPSP at London Book Fair 2010
spacer
19 April 2010
Exploiting Licensing Opportunities Through Book Fairs: Translation, Digital and Other Subsidiary Rights
spacer
11 May 2010
Text Mining for Publishers
spacer
ALPSP Training
spacer
10 February 2010
Web 2.0: Online communities and social media (1002WTO) ** Fully Booked**
spacer
23 February 2010
Project Management for Publishing (1002PMP)
spacer
2 March 2010
Introduction to Journals Marketing (1003IJM)
spacer
9 March 2010
Strategic Journals Finance (1003SJF)
spacer
25 March 2010
How to be a Successful Journal Editor (1003SJE)
spacer
4 May 2010
Geneva: Maximising your Secondary Rights (1005GMS)
spacer
4 May 2010
North American Chapter: Introduction to Journals Publishing (1005NAJ)
spacer
5 May 2010
Geneva: Web 2.0. Online communities and social media (1005GOC)
spacer
7 May 2010
North American Chapter: High Impact Online Marketing - the Evolution of Online Communities and Social Media Marketing (1005NAH)
spacer
11 May 2010
Taking eBooks to Market (1005TEM)
spacer
About ALPSP  |  Member Benefits  |  Training & Events  |  Information  |  Research & Publications  |  Networking  |  Contact Us
Online Submission and Peer Review Systems



On Line Submission.

A review of currently available systems and the experiences of authors, referees, editors and publishers.
This ALPSP report gives an objective account of the current state of play of online peer review systems. It provides a comprehensive overview of all the available online submission systems, describing their features and offering a framework for analysing and choosing among them. It then presents the results of three specially-commissioned substantial surveys of authors and referees, editors and publishers.


Mark Ware, Mark Ware Consulting Ltd

ISBN 0-907341-29-2
134 pages, paperback, 297 x 145mm
Published October 2005
ALPSP members: £55, $99, €125
ALPSP non-members: £95, $175, €220

The PDF is free to ALPSP Members to download from the link below. (NB Members will need to log in to access the link. Email info@alpsp.org if you do not have a username and password)

ORDER paperback in:    [Pounds Sterling]     [US Dollars]     [Euro



Online submissions and peer review systems for journals have existed for less than a decade and have become increasingly common in the last few years with the development of web-based services supplied on an ASP (Application Service Provider, i.e. hosted) basis.

Authors certainly appear ready to embrace online submissions, with anecdotal reports of rapid switch-over to online once it is introduced. There are similarly anecdotal accounts of increased submissions, reduced refereeing times, reduced administrative time and costs. There is also speculation about potential impacts on author and referee behaviours: for instance, there may be the potential for authors to create 'pecking lists' of the most favoured journals, bombarding those at the top with submissions while only trying those towards the bottom once other rejections have come in.

This research report will be of interest to all those involved in peer review. It will be especially valuable to publishers, learned societies and journal editors who are contemplating the introduction of an online system, or a possible change to a new system, and to the online system vendors.

Contents

  • Summary
  • Part I: Online submission and peer review systems
  • Part II: Survey findings
  • Introduction
  • Objectives of the study
  • Part I: Online submission and peer review systems
  • Current developments in online submission and peer review systems
  • Overview of online submission and peer review systems' functionality
  • A typical paper's path through the system
  • Other features
  • Current systems
  • Choosing an online system
  • Part II: Survey findings
  • Author and referee survey
  • Editor survey
  • Publisher survey
  • Appendix 1: Author and referee survey - Appendix 2: Editor survey
  • Appendix 3: Publisher survey

ORDER paperback in:    [Pounds Sterling]     [US Dollars]     [Euro


<< Back
spacer spacer spacer
spacer